there you go ridinfast03, that's what polished is really supposed to look like! almost like chrome.
here's a before and after of my polish job on my aluminum fork sliders, steel rotor and brake caliper.
i actually went back a couple weeks ago and pulled the rotor to hit it again w/ an orbital sander cuz it's ridiculously hardened so i wasn't able to get a good cut on it the first time around. but you get the idea from the sliders i think....